By Sal Greco
A significant shakeup occurred inside New York City government on Thursday as Anthony Miranda was removed from his position as Sheriff of the City of New York and former NYPD Lieutenant Edwin Raymond was selected to replace him, according to multiple media reports published after news of the move began circulating publicly.
Notably, The Sal Greco Show publicly reported Miranda’s termination and Raymond’s impending appointment before major media outlets confirmed the development through City Hall so hours later, mainstream media organizations began contacting City Hall and publishing confirmation that Mayor Zohran Mamdani had fired Miranda and selected Raymond as his replacement. However, despite The Sal Greco Show publicly breaking the story first, no credit was given by those outlets for the initial reporting.
The End of the Anthony Miranda Era
Anthony Miranda was appointed New York City Sheriff in May 2022 by then-Mayor Eric Adams after a lengthy career in law enforcement and public service. Prior to becoming sheriff, Miranda served in the NYPD and later became associated with the National Latino Officers Association.
His tenure as sheriff, however, became increasingly controversial.
Over the past several years, Miranda faced numerous public allegations and investigations that generated headlines throughout New York City.
Among the allegations publicly reported were:
- Claims by deputy sheriffs and union officials regarding workplace retaliation, discrimination, and nepotism within the Sheriff’s Office.
- Accusations that department resources and executive positions were improperly utilized.
- Allegations that emergency lights and sirens were used improperly.
- Reports that the New York City Department of Investigation examined the handling of cash seizures during enforcement actions involving illegal cannabis businesses.
- Additional allegations reported by media outlets involving hiring practices and background investigations for deputy sheriff candidates.
It is important to note that many of these matters consisted of allegations, complaints, investigations, or claims reported by news organizations and unions. Public reporting does not establish criminal wrongdoing, and Miranda has denied various accusations made against him.
Nevertheless, the controversies followed him throughout his tenure and ultimately became part of the public discussion surrounding his leadership of the Sheriff’s Office.
Edwin Raymond: From NYPD Whistleblower to NYC Sheriff
Miranda’s replacement, Edwin Raymond, enters the position with a vastly different public profile.
Raymond spent approximately 15 years with the NYPD and became nationally known after joining other minority officers in a federal lawsuit alleging discriminatory arrest and summons quota practices within the department.
The lawsuit brought significant public attention to allegations concerning policing practices and internal department pressure. Raymond subsequently became a prominent voice advocating for police reform and accountability.
In 2020, Raymond made history by running for public office while still serving as an NYPD lieutenant. He later retired from the NYPD in 2023 and authored a book discussing his experiences inside the department.
Mayor Mamdani praised Raymond upon announcing the appointment, describing him as a public servant committed to accountability, effectiveness, and public trust. Raymond likewise expressed gratitude for the opportunity to serve as New York City’s new sheriff.
Whether supporters or critics agree with Raymond’s views, his appointment clearly signals a dramatic shift in philosophy and leadership style from the previous administration.
The Importance of Being First — And Being Right
The events surrounding Miranda’s removal also highlight an issue that has become increasingly common in modern media.
The Sal Greco Show publicly reported the termination and replacement before larger media organizations confirmed the story. Yet once mainstream outlets obtained confirmation from City Hall, they proceeded with their own reporting without acknowledging the source that first placed the information into the public domain.
That reality has become familiar to many independent journalists and content creators.
Equally familiar are the critics who routinely claim they knew a story before anyone else. Such claims are easy to make after the fact. What matters is whether the information was publicly reported, documented, and timestamped before everyone else.
If someone truly knew beforehand, the obvious question becomes: Where was the public post? Where was the article? Where was the video?
Knowledge that remains unpublished is not reporting.
Many of the same detractors frequently boast about having massive “networks” or subscriber counts. Yet public analytics tools often tell a different story. Anyone interested in examining audience metrics can review publicly available statistics through sites such as Social Blade and compare subscriber counts, engagement levels, and viewership trends for themselves.
Ultimately, numbers alone do not establish credibility.
What separates The Sal Greco Show from much of the commentary ecosystem is a commitment to presenting evidence, identifying sources, documenting facts, and publishing information promptly. The objective is not rumor, innuendo, or anonymous gossip. The objective is to present verifiable information and allow the audience to evaluate the evidence for themselves.
In an era where narratives often travel faster than facts, accuracy still matters.
And on the story of Anthony Miranda’s termination and Edwin Raymond’s appointment, The Sal Greco Show was first.